Specialty Contact Lenses

6 Signs Your Contacts Will Never Feel Right

Illustration of a barely used box of contact lenses and a lens case set aside in a bathroom cabinet, with glasses on the counter below
Specialty Contacts

Six signs your current contacts will never feel right.

If you have decided you are just “not a contacts person,” it may be the lens, not your eyes. Here is how to tell, and what actually comes next.

By Dr. Matthew Karres, OD Optometrist and owner, COVE New Albany 6 min read

Somewhere at home you have a barely used box of contacts and a conclusion you reached somewhere along the way: your eyes are too dry, too sensitive, too “difficult,” and glasses are just easier. Sometimes that is the right call. But often the real problem is that you were fit with a standard, off-the-shelf lens that was never going to work for your particular eyes, and a different kind of lens can make a meaningful difference.

Standard soft contacts come in a limited range of shapes and sizes. Eyes do not. If yours fall outside that range, trying another brand of the same kind of lens rarely helps. Below are six signs you may be in that situation, and what is worth trying instead. We see patients for this across New Albany and Central Ohio.

Illustration of a barely used box of contact lenses and a lens case set aside in a bathroom cabinet, with glasses on the counter below
Plate I  ·  Hero
The shelf where contacts go to be given up on. If this looks familiar, the lens was probably the problem, not you.
01

The six signs.

1. They are comfortable in the morning and miserable by afternoon

If you carry rewetting drops everywhere, or the lenses come out by mid-afternoon because you cannot stand them another hour, the lens may not be matching your tear film or your eye’s surface. A lens designed for your eye, or one that vaults the cornea entirely, can often improve the afternoon crash.

2. Your vision is “almost” clear but never crisp

If your contacts get you close but leave everything slightly soft, especially at night, the lens may not be correcting the full shape of your eye. This is common with astigmatism and with corneas that are not perfectly regular.

3. You have been told you have astigmatism, keratoconus, or an irregular cornea

These are different situations, and they matter differently. Regular astigmatism is often corrected well with toric soft lenses. Keratoconus and other irregular corneas are another story: they often need a lens that creates its own smooth optical surface, which is what rigid and scleral lenses are designed to do.

If keratoconus is part of your picture, your next read is scleral lenses for keratoconus →

4. You have had LASIK or a corneal issue and contacts feel different now

Refractive surgery, a transplant, or an injury can change the shape of the cornea. Some of these eyes still do fine in conventional lenses; others see and feel dramatically better in a specialty design made for that new shape. Which one you are is exactly what an evaluation sorts out.

If surgery or injury changed your cornea, your next read is scleral lenses for irregular and post-surgical corneas →

5. Your eyes are genuinely dry and lenses make it worse

For real ocular-surface dryness, a properly fitted scleral lens can help many people, because it holds a reservoir of fluid over the cornea while it is worn rather than sitting on a dry surface. Dryness can have several causes, so sometimes it takes more than a lens change, and we will tell you if so.

If dryness is your main complaint, your next read is scleral lenses for dry eye →

6. You have “tried everything” and a doctor said you are hard to fit

“Hard to fit” usually means hard to fit with standard lenses. It does not have to mean impossible: often it means standard lenses were the wrong tool, and an evaluation can tell whether a different design is realistic for your eyes. It is often the point at which another doctor refers a patient to us.

If you have heard those words, your next read is hard-to-fit contacts in New Albany →

“I’m not a contacts person” is frequently just “I’ve only been offered one kind of contact.” There are several kinds, and they are very different.

02

What to try next.

Not another box of the same lens, for a start. If a few of these signs sound familiar, the step that changes things is a specialty contact lens evaluation, where we map the surface of your eye and fit to its actual shape. The main options:

Illustration of three contact lens designs side by side next to a fingertip, showing their different sizes and shapes
Not interchangeable: a standard soft lens, a smaller rigid gas-permeable lens, and a larger scleral lens. Different shapes for different eyes.
Custom soft lenses made to your eye’s measurements, beyond the stock range.
Gas-permeable (GP) lenses that create a crisp optical surface for irregular corneas. Read more about gas-permeable contacts →
Scleral lenses that vault over the cornea entirely and rest on the white of the eye, a design we often reach for with keratoconus, post-surgical corneas, and significant dryness.
Cross-section diagram of a scleral contact lens vaulting over an irregular cornea with a fluid reservoir underneath
How a scleral lens works: it vaults the cornea entirely and rests on the white of the eye, holding a thin fluid reservoir beneath it. For many “difficult” eyes, that reservoir is the difference.

These often take more than a single appointment to fit well, because getting them right matters more than getting them fast. For many people who had written off contacts, it is worth one more conversation before they give up for good.

03

What a specialty evaluation includes.

A COVE technician performing a corneal topography scan, with the resulting elevation map displayed on screen
A corneal topography scan in progress at COVE. The map on screen shows the shape of the eye in detail, well beyond what a prescription alone tells us.

It starts with the shape of your eye, not just your prescription. We use corneal topography to map the surface in detail, and we weigh that map alongside your prescription, your tear film, and how your eyes have handled lenses before to choose whether a custom soft, gas-permeable, or scleral design is the right starting point. That measurement step is what separates a specialty fit from a routine contact lens check.

From there we work with trial lenses. You wear a diagnostic lens, we assess how it sits and how you see, and we refine from there. For sclerals and other custom designs, it is normal for this to take a few visits to dial in. We do not cut the process short to save a trip. See what to expect at a contact lens exam →

Dr. Matthew Karres, OD, of Central Ohio Vision and Eyecare in New Albany
Written by
Dr. Matthew Karres, OD
Dr. Karres is an optometrist and the owner of Central Ohio Vision and Eyecare in New Albany. A New Albany High School graduate and former US Army combat medic, he earned his Doctor of Optometry at The Ohio State University and has spent years fitting children and adults in everyday and specialty contact lenses.

If your contacts have never felt right, it is worth one conversation before you give up on them. A specialty evaluation can show you what is realistic for your eyes.

Book a specialty contact lens evaluation

Or call us at (614) 933-0575. We see patients from New Albany, Gahanna, Westerville, and across Central Ohio.

Keep reading
04

Common questions.

Q.01 Why do my contacts dry out every afternoon?

Often because the lens is not matched to your eye’s surface or tear film. A custom or scleral lens can often improve the afternoon dryness, though dryness has several causes and sometimes needs more than a lens change.

Q.02 Can I wear contacts if I have keratoconus or astigmatism?

Frequently, yes, with the right lens. Regular astigmatism is often handled well by toric soft lenses. Keratoconus and other irregular corneas usually need a gas-permeable or scleral design instead of standard soft contacts.

Q.03 I had LASIK years ago. Can I still wear contacts?

Often yes, but it may take a specialty lens designed for post-surgical eyes rather than an off-the-shelf one.

Q.04 Is “hard to fit” a dead end?

Usually not. It often means standard lenses have not worked, and a specialty evaluation can determine whether a different lens design is a realistic option. It is a common reason patients are referred to us.

Q.05 Does insurance cover specialty contacts?

It depends on your plan. Some vision plans through VSP or EyeMed include a medically necessary contact lens benefit. Whether it applies comes down to your specific plan and whether your case qualifies. We verify what we can in advance and confirm qualification together at the evaluation.

Central Ohio Vision and Eyecare, New Albany, Ohio. This article is general education, not medical advice. Talk with your eye doctor about what is right for your eyes.